Shopify subscriptions: how to sell products as a subscription

A customer who orders automatically every month is the calmest revenue there is. For products that run out, like coffee, supplements or a day cream, a subscription in your online store is often smart. In Shopify it's easier than many people think.

Simon van RensUpdated 17 November 20264 min read
Short answer

You set up Shopify subscriptions with the free Shopify Subscriptions app, or with a more extensive app like Recharge, Seal or Appstle. Per product you choose how often it's delivered and what discount the subscriber gets. It works best for products that run out, with a small discount and easy cancellation.

When people talk about a Shopify subscription, they mean one of two things: the plan you pay Shopify yourself, or selling products as a subscription. This page is about the second. What Shopify itself costs per month, you'll read in Shopify pricing.

Which products does a subscription work for?

For products that run out and that people buy again and again:

  • coffee, tea and matcha;
  • supplements;
  • a day cream, cleanser or shampoo;
  • refills.

For a product someone buys once or wants to try first, it works less well. There, a sample pack is often the better first step.

How do you set up a subscription with Shopify?

With the free Shopify Subscriptions app:

  1. Install the app from the Shopify App Store.
  2. Create a subscription plan: how often it's delivered, for example every four or eight weeks, and what discount the subscriber gets.
  3. Link the plan to the products you want to offer as a subscription.
  4. Check that your theme shows the "one-time or subscription" choice on the product page.
  5. Place a test order.

After that, customers manage their subscription themselves in their account: skip, pause or cancel.

Watch the payment methods. For a subscription, a payment has to be able to repeat automatically. Local methods like iDEAL (the most used online payment method in the Netherlands) and Klarna can hardly do that in Shopify. Subscribers then pay by credit card or PayPal. Say so upfront on the product page, so nobody gets a surprise at checkout. More about payments is in iDEAL in Shopify.

When do you choose a more extensive app?

Shopify Subscriptions is enough for a simple subscription. A more extensive app, like Recharge, Seal or Appstle, pays off if you want more:

  • a box the customer puts together herself;
  • gifts or extra discount after a number of deliveries;
  • a customer portal in your own branding;
  • deeper connections with your email.

Start simple. You can always expand later. A subscription that runs well with one product says more than a complicated system nobody uses.

Curious where this plays out in your store?

Get your free store audit →

How do you show the subscription on your product page?

The choice between one-time and subscription belongs right next to the price and the buy button. Show:

  • what the product costs as a one-time purchase;
  • what it costs as a subscription, with the saving in euros;
  • how often it's delivered, with the option to change that;
  • that you can cancel at any time.

That last line matters more than it seems. Many people have had bad experiences with subscriptions that are hard to cancel. So state it clearly.

Which discount works?

Many stores call this subscribe and save: if you subscribe, you pay a bit less. A small discount is usually enough. For many customers, convenience is the real reason. A few rules:

  • Keep it simple. One fixed discount on every subscription is clearer than tiers.
  • Check your margin, including shipping. With a subscription you pay that on every delivery.
  • Free shipping for subscribers is often more attractive than extra discount.

How do you keep subscribers?

Cancelling has to be easy. That sounds contradictory, but people are more likely to subscribe when they know they can get out just like that. What does help:

  • A reminder before the next delivery, so nobody is caught off guard.
  • Skip and pause instead of only cancel.
  • A personal email with the first delivery: how to use it, what to expect.

More on customers who come back is in loyalty and repeat purchases.

What do you measure?

After a few months, look at three numbers: how many customers take a subscription, how long they stay on average, and what a subscriber brings you in total compared with a one-time customer. If you see many subscribers cancel after one or two deliveries, look at the delivery frequency. Often it's too high, so people build up a stock.

Does this work for coffee and matcha?

That's exactly where it works. Coffee and matcha run out, and customers often have a fixed taste. How I approach that for coffee and tea stores, you'll read in coffee, tea and matcha.

Checklist

  1. Pick the products that run out.
  2. Install Shopify Subscriptions and create one plan.
  3. Choose a small discount or free shipping.
  4. Put the choice clearly on the product page.
  5. Send a reminder before every delivery.

Frequently asked questions

Is your question not here? Just message me.

How do I sell products as a subscription in Shopify?

With the free Shopify Subscriptions app. You create a plan with the delivery frequency and the discount, and link it to your products. Customers manage the subscription themselves in their account.

Is Shopify Subscriptions free?

The app itself is free to install. You do pay the normal transaction fees for every payment.

What discount do I give on a subscription?

A small discount is usually enough, because convenience is the real reason. Free shipping for subscribers often works just as well. Always check your margin.

Can customers cancel their subscription themselves?

Yes, in their customer account they can skip, pause or cancel. Make that easy: people are more likely to subscribe when they know they can get out just like that.

Does iDEAL work for a subscription?

Usually not. iDEAL and Klarna hardly work in Shopify for automatically recurring payments. Subscribers then pay by credit card or PayPal. Say so upfront on your product page.

Does a subscription suit your products?

I look at which products lend themselves to it, and how to show it on your product pages without it feeling pushy.

Get your free store audit →

Rather ask something first? Message me or email simon@lecollectif.nl.

Simon at his laptop
Message me
Step 1 of 3

Which store should I look at?

I can see the platform and industry myself. You don't need to prepare anything.

I only use your details for the audit and to send you the video. Privacy

Roughly how many orders per month?

What do you want more of first?

Thanks. An audit doesn't make much sense yet.

With fewer than 100 orders a month there isn't enough data to say anything useful. I will send you the list of tips I would give any new store, so you can pick them up yourself.

Thanks. Your request is in.

Within 48 hours on working days you get a personal video about your store in your inbox.

Sending…

That didn't work.

Try again, or just send your store on WhatsApp to +31 6 45 79 01 58 or email simon@lecollectif.nl.