A loyalty program for your online store: from sample to full size

Most stores put a lot of money and effort into the first order. The second order they leave to chance. That's exactly where the money is.

Simon van RensUpdated 17 November 20265 min read
Short answer

A loyalty program only works for a small online store once the second order is in good shape. Start with a good flow after the first purchase or the sample, measure how many customers come back, and only then choose between reward points, a subscription or a fixed perk for loyal customers.

Stores rent their customers. You pay for every new visitor through ads, and when you stop, nothing comes in anymore. A customer who comes back without you paying again is therefore worth the most. That's what customer retention is about. A loyalty program can help with that. But usually not as the first step.

Does a loyalty program work for a small online store?

Sometimes, but only if you already know how many customers come back on their own.

A loyalty program is a fixed way to reward returning customers, for example with points, discounts or perks. It works like an amplifier. If a reasonable share of your customers already comes back, you push that up. If almost nobody comes back, there's nothing to amplify.

With the founders I talk to, I often see the same thing. A points app is running, but nobody knows how many customers order a second time. Then that's where I start. Measure first, then make the second order easy, and only after that a program.

How much is a loyal customer worth?

What a customer brings in on average over the whole time they buy from you is called the customer lifetime value.

A simple way to estimate it:

  1. Take your average order value.
  2. Multiply by the average number of orders per customer per year.
  3. Multiply by the number of years a customer stays on average.
  4. Subtract your cost of goods, shipping and payment costs. Then you have the value in margin, and that's what counts.

A worked example, as a rough estimate with assumptions. A customer orders €45 on average, does that three times a year and stays two years. That's €270 in revenue. If your margin after costs is half, that customer is worth about €135. That number tells you how much you can spend to win and keep a customer.

The most important number here is the number of orders per customer. That's where you have the most influence. In Shopify Analytics you see how many of your customers are returning. How to calculate customer lifetime value exactly is in customer lifetime value for your online store.

How do you get customers to come back after a sample?

Send your message when the sample is almost finished, with an explanation and a reason to order the full size now.

In skincare, samples are a strong entry point. But the step from sample to full size often goes wrong, because nothing happens after delivery. This is how I set it up:

  1. Know how long your sample lasts. If it's a week, plan the first message a few days after delivery.
  2. Explain first, sell after. How do you use it, where in your routine, what should you watch out for.
  3. Credit the sample. For example a code worth the value of the sample on the full size. Then the step doesn't feel like paying again.
  4. Ask for a review. A short question, at a moment when the customer has really used the product.
  5. Send one last reminder. Then you stop. Anyone who doesn't respond gets a regular newsletter later.

Points, subscription or discount: what works?

That depends on how often your product runs out.

TypeHow it worksFits
Reward pointsPoints per order, redeemable for a discountStores with many different products and frequent small orders
SubscriptionRegular delivery, often with a perkProducts that run out: coffee, matcha, supplements, refills
Discount on the second orderOne-time code after the first purchaseEvery store, as a first step
Fixed perk without discountFree shipping, early access, a sample with every orderBrands that don't want to erode their price

For coffee and matcha, a subscription is the obvious choice. The product runs out, and the customer doesn't want to reorder every time. More on that on the page for coffee, tea and matcha stores.

For skincare, a fixed perk often works better than a points program. Think of free shipping for loyal customers, or a new sample with every order. That also fits well with your free shipping threshold.

Discounts work fast, but don't get customers used to them. Anyone who always gets a code waits for the next one.

Work out what a little more conversion is worth to your store.

Open the revenue calculator →

Which emails belong with a loyalty program?

A program without emails is a button nobody finds.

At minimum these messages belong with it:

  • Thank you after the first order, with an explanation of the product and what the customer can expect.
  • The sample or refill message, at the moment the product is almost finished.
  • A review request, once the customer has used the product.
  • A winback email for customers who haven't ordered in a while.
  • A program update, for example how many points someone has.

How to set up those flows in Klaviyo is on the page about Klaviyo email flows.

How do you measure repeat purchases?

Look at three things: the share of returning customers, the time to the second order and the revenue from loyal customers.

  1. Share of returning customers. How many of your customers ordered more than once? You see this in Shopify Analytics.
  2. Time to the second order. After how many days does a customer come back on average? Time your emails to match.
  3. Revenue from loyal customers. What share of your revenue comes from people who bought before?

Measure this per month and compare with the same month a year earlier. How to set that up with GA4 and Shopify is in tracking and measuring. In my dashboard these numbers sit next to your traffic from Google, so you see whether new and loyal customers are growing.

Where do you start this week?

Start small, and measure before you build anything.

  1. Look up in Shopify Analytics how many of your customers ordered a second time.
  2. Check how many days there are on average between the first and second order.
  3. Turn on one email that goes out just before that moment.

Only once that email works is it time for a program with points or a subscription.

Do you include samples? Then read how to turn a sample into a full-size order.

Frequently asked questions

Is your question not here? Just message me.

Which app do you use for a loyalty program in Shopify?

There are many apps for points and subscriptions. Choose one that connects well with your email tool, so points and perks show up in your emails. A simple fixed perk, like free shipping for loyal customers, you can often arrange without an app.

What is a good percentage of returning customers?

That varies a lot per product. Coffee and supplements run out and are repurchased more often than, say, a gift item. So compare yourself mainly with your own number from last year.

Doesn't a loyalty program cost too much margin?

It can, especially with high discounts. Run the numbers with your customer lifetime value in margin. Perks without discounts, like early access or a sample, often cost less and keep your price intact.

Do I need customer consent for emails in a loyalty program?

For marketing email you need consent, or you email existing customers about similar products with a clear unsubscribe link. Have someone with legal knowledge check the exact rules for your situation.

When does a subscription work for my online store?

For products that run out, like coffee, supplements or a day cream. Start with a small discount and make canceling easy, then people are more willing to try it. In <a href="/en/industries/coffee-tea-matcha/">coffee, tea and matcha</a> you can see how that works.

Does a trial kit work to win new customers?

Yes, if the step to the full product is easy. For example, give back the amount of the trial kit as credit on the first big purchase. How to offer that in the cart is in <a href="/en/cart-upsells/">cart upsells</a>.

How many customers come back to you?

In the free scan I look at your first and second order, and where the biggest opportunity is.

Get your free store audit →

Rather ask something first? Message me or email simon@lecollectif.nl.

Simon at his laptop
Message me
Step 1 of 3

Which store should I look at?

I can see the platform and industry myself. You don't need to prepare anything.

I only use your details for the audit and to send you the video. Privacy

Roughly how many orders per month?

What do you want more of first?

Thanks. An audit doesn't make much sense yet.

With fewer than 100 orders a month there isn't enough data to say anything useful. I will send you the list of tips I would give any new store, so you can pick them up yourself.

Thanks. Your request is in.

Within 48 hours on working days you get a personal video about your store in your inbox.

Sending…

That didn't work.

Try again, or just send your store on WhatsApp to +31 6 45 79 01 58 or email simon@lecollectif.nl.